Apologies, reparations, forget it! off with all their heads (metaphorically speaking)!

Drucken
Workers' Fight workplace bulletin editorials
4 November 2026

King Charles was sorry this Monday - after getting soaking wet in Antigua. But as to being sorry about the transatlantic slave trade? Not quite yet...

    That said, this awkward old man on his "royal tour" couldn't look more apologetic! He and his wife are truly sorry sights. It's surprising how, nevertheless, some of their Caribbean island subjects still turn up to cheer and clap.

    But there you have it. We live in a comically grotesque world, whose inequalities are deeply entrenched. And this is precisely thanks to the imperial system, whose foundation was slavery and the colonies - as those who demand reparations today, quite rightly point out.

    Bizarrely, certain historical legal formalities dictate that Charles may not apologise for benefiting from slavery, even if he might want to. He has to get parliament's permission.

    And here the many ironies just pile up! Parliament rules his tongue, thanks to the English revolution of the 1640s, which first dethroned the king, beheaded him, and then restored him as a figurehead. And it's this (very English) revolution which, having first ousted feudalism, opened up the seas to bountiful trade. Including the slave trade. And so the British came to accumulate capital much ahead of their rivals - laying the basis for the industrial revolution in England, a new class of wage slaves in the factories - and, the abolition of the slave trade!

    But there's the usual dirty twist to the tale when it comes to the British ruling class. Their unilateral "ending" of the trade in slaves wasn't thanks to their morality. By patrolling the West African coasts they curtailed the activity of their Spanish, Dutch and Portuguese rivals, and beat them to imperialism's post.

Andy Burnham says sorry?

Anyway, today Andy Burnham has to decide whether finally, ~200+ years later, he should make a formal apology and maybe even offer reparations to the heads of the so-called "Commonwealth" - that absurd misnomer, since there's nothing "common" about the wealth still in the hands of British capital and Britain's big landowners, let alone the monarchy. The king's personal wealth is £680m, his Duchy of Lancaster is worth £1.8bn and the Crown Estate £15.6bn!

    Actually, Burnham's article in the Guardian this Monday helpfully singled out the main factor in slavery's abolition back in 1807. It wasn't do-gooders like William Wilberforce, so much as the refusal of Manchester textile workers to make cloth out of the cotton picked by the hands of slaves!

    And today, let's be clear, reparations - if there are any - are unlikely to reach those who really need them - i.e., the modern wage slaves (and unemployed) of the islands. That money will be available for use at the discretion of the local political leaderships, who gratefully preside over that fake independence "awarded" a few decades ago by imperial Britain. And while they gain personal advantage from it, their economies are still locked in a state of dependence (just like all other former colonies) on their former colonial masters. Which is why there was - and indeed still is - no alternative to "Windrush": emigration to the "motherland" to find a wage and a decent future...

Shabana Mahmood's peanut gallery

That's the true legacy of slavery. So when Shabana Mahmood stands up in the House of Commons playing to the hypocritical anti-migrant gallery with her new rules for settlement, she gives the game away. Because as many as 280,000 care workers have come over the seas to work for a pittance looking after the sick, elderly and disabled. Plus several million health workers... As they always have in the past. Because there were never enough British-born carers. And there never will be, as the population ages further. So despite her many concessions to the racist, anti- immigrant lobbies, Mahmood has to allow "key" workers, at least, the right to settle.

    As it happens, Mahmood's own origin is another former colony - Pakistan - which along with Afghanistan, the Middle East and North Africa has the most people living in extreme poverty today - and is the only region where such deprivation is on the increase. Whose legacy is that? Do we even need to ask?

    Afghanistan has never recovered from the devastation of the US and British so-called "war on terror". Gaza, the West Bank, Lebanon and Iran are all still under siege and under fire - with all British governments (including Burnham's) supporting the ongoing lsraeli/US terror against their populations.

    So reparations for slavery? Meaning something which repairs damage? There is no such thing in this world order, forcibly imposed, as it is, by the rich imperialist powers. Slavery has merely evolved into new forms of oppression and exploitation.

    It's only a revolution which can change this. And the revolutionaries will come out of the ranks of the today's wage slaves. They won't be fighting for "sovereignty" or "compensation", but for an entirely new social order, based on an economy organised to produce for need - where the wages' system itself is abolished! It's called international communism...